leadimage

    Holy Orders and the Sacrificial Priesthood

    At the heart of the separation of Catholics and Protestants lies a disagreement about the ecclesial hierarchy. Who are the rightful shepherds of Christ’s flock? This article will examine the Catholic Church’s doctrine of the sacrificial priesthood, and in doing so, will lay the foundation for our subsequent discussion on the critical issue of apostolic succession. We will argue for the following four claims. The hierarchical difference between the clergy and the laity was ordained by God and is supported by the Biblical data. Continue Reading…

Blog

Please read our posting guidelines before commenting.  Subscribe to blog only.

August 31, 2010

I Believe in the Rapture-and it Happens Very Often

Filed under: Blog Posts — Tags: , , , , , , — J. Andrew Deane @ 11:17 pm

Becoming Reformed after a six year sojourn in the evangelical world of Calvary Chapel, I was pleased to give up speculations about the end of the world via the notion of an imminent Rapture. There was a lack of historical support for thinking this way, and there was also a pleasing emphasis on Scripture as opposed to the newspaper. But every once in awhile, I must admit that the pure joy of thinking about the coming of God Himself to earth seemed to be too distant for someone like me to continue to enjoy. Was there any place for a continued hope of God coming to earth? Or was all of that joy based on predictions that so often never came to pass? (Continue Reading…)

August 30, 2010

J.R.R. Tolkien’s Sacramental World, Part Three: Language

Filed under: Blog Posts — Tags: , — Andrew Preslar @ 12:11 am

This is the third in a three part series. Part One may be read here.1 In this post, I want to make a few remarks about how language, particularly in its stylistic or aesthetic aspect, relates to reality. I will do this by way of briefly indicating how Middle Earth is rooted in language, and how language functions in that world. This bit will be extremely rudimentary (relative to the depth and complexity of the subject), but should at least illustrate the point I hope to make; namely, that translations of biblical and liturgical texts should be beautiful and traditional, even if this is accompanied (or constituted) by a certain strangeness, or unfamiliarity, as compared to contemporary and common forms of speech. (Continue Reading…)

  1. The first part deals with Memory. Part Two, which considers Matter, is still in the works.  I am sticking to the order of conception, not the order of posting, in numbering this series. []

August 18, 2010

Bank Accounts and Justification

Filed under: Blog Posts — Tags: , , — Tim A. Troutman @ 8:00 am

Recently a friend reminded me of a common Protestant analogy regarding salvation and merit. The analogy is that sinners have a ‘bank account’ wherewith to ‘pay’ for their eternal salvation. The problem is that man cannot possibly have enough in this account to pay the ‘amount due.’ Faith in Christ is equivalent to having a blank check payable from Christ’s own account of merit. So in that analogy, God does not withdraw the ‘merit’ from the sinner’s account but from Christ’s account. (Continue Reading…)

August 16, 2010

δικαιόω: a morphological, lexical and historical analysis

Filed under: Blog Posts — Tags: , , — David Pell @ 12:44 pm

The impetus for this brief post is Bryan’s recent response to Rose in the thread on St. Augustine on Law and Grace. Rose asks about the contention she has heard from Protestants that St. Augustine did not understand the meaning of δικαιόω (dikaiow), which means, according to the Protestants, to count righteous rather than to make righteous. Bryan’s comments on the lexical fallacy and the tradition of interpretation are great, but the Catholic position is also not without its own lexical merit. In this post I will examine the morphology of δικαιόω, show that there is sufficient lexical evidence to support the factitive/causal interpretation and briefly touch on the translation history of the gospels into Latin. (Continue Reading…)

August 15, 2010

The Last Road

Filed under: Blog Posts — Tags: — Andrew Preslar @ 2:24 pm

This is not exactly a story, though it is partly autobiographical, and partly allegorical, or perhaps just highly allusive. Mostly, it is a farrago, which I must have written after reading something by Belloc. Anyway, I found it, finished it, touched it up, and here it is. The whole thing is called “The Last Road.”

(Continue Reading…)

August 12, 2010

Another new Contributor – Stephen Wilkins

Filed under: Blog Posts — Tim A. Troutman @ 1:34 am

Allow me to introduce Stephen Wilkins, our third new contributor in the month of August. Stephen is a long time regular in the combox of Called to Communion. You may have seen him comment as “Wilkins.”  Stephen, a convert from the PCA, will be helping us fill an editing role and will also be writing for CTC.  He holds an MA in English and is currently pursuing his second MA, this time in theology, at Franciscan University. He has formerly volunteered as proofreader for The Glass, a literary journal published in the UK by the Christian Literary Studies Group. (Continue Reading…)

August 10, 2010

I love the Orthodox too much to be Orthodox (or How I learned to stop worrying and love the atomic bomb of Holy Orders)

Filed under: Blog Posts — Tags: , , , , , , — J. Andrew Deane @ 6:00 am

In a previous blog post, I wrote about the joys and similarities which bind together the Catholic and Orthodox Churches. As tragic as our lack of full communion with one another is, there is a bond which unites us even now while our sacramental reunion is mostly a hope for the future. This bond is so deep in my estimation that it is with much fear and trembling that I write this post. But to be honest to my conscience and to my understanding of the Apostolic Churches that are not in full communion with one another, I must state it loud and state it clear: I love the Orthodox too much to be Orthodox. (Continue Reading…)

August 9, 2010

The Heroes of the New Covenant

Filed under: Blog Posts — Tags: , , , — Bryan Cross @ 5:35 pm

Recently Juan Callejas wrote about the relics of St. John Bosco (Don Bosco) being brought on a tour of Guatemala. Juan described his own perplexity at the eagerness and excitement of Catholics upon the arrival of the saint’s relics.1 (Continue Reading…)

  1. These relics will be brought on a tour of the US and Canada this Fall; see the schedule here. []

August 6, 2010

The Denominational Marketplace

Filed under: Blog Posts — Tags: , — Tom Brown @ 8:30 pm

Just a few months before I was certain I needed to enter the Catholic Church, I wrote the following post on a blog I had been using to write out my thoughts about discerning the Church. I re-post it here, with some edits that seem appropriate now that I am Catholic, to reach Called to Communion’s particular audience.

An early 2009 Christianity Today contained a provocative article entitled Jesus Is Not A Brand1  In it, the author, Rev. Tyler Wigg-Stevenson, analyzes the conflation of evangelism with sales marketing. He states: (Continue Reading…)

  1. Tyler Wigg-Stevenson, p. 20, Jan. 2009. []

August 5, 2010

Introducing – Barrett Turner

Filed under: Blog Posts — Tim A. Troutman @ 8:00 am

Our second new contributor is Barrett Turner. Barrett was still a Protestant when he first commented at CTC. Now he’s in the doctoral program at Catholic University of America. Here’s Barrett’s bio:

Though raised United Methodist, Barrett was heavily influenced by Reformed University Fellowship and a local PCA church at the University of Virginia. During his time at Covenant Theological Seminary after college, he became increasingly intrigued and troubled by “the Catholic question”. As a result, he and his wife began a period of discernment and eventually RCIA. They were received into full communion with the Catholic Church by Archbishop Robert Carlson of St. Louis at the 2010 Easter Vigil. Barrett is currently a doctoral student in moral theology at the Catholic University of America.

Barrett, welcome to the team!


For older posts, visit the archives.

    Called to Communion Podcast

    Download Individual Podcast Epsiodes | Subscribe to the podcast



    August 25, 2010

    Episode 14 – A Presuppositional Apologist Becomes Catholic

    Tom Riello interviews Marc Ayers on the topic of his conversion to the Catholic Church. Marc was a ‘disciple’ of Dr. Greg Bahnsen. Hear him tell how his presuppositional apologetic method helped him see the need for a divinely instituted authority, namely the Catholic Church.

     

    To download the mp3, click here.

    May 30, 2010

    Episode 13 – Holy Orders

    Filed under: Podcast — Tags: , , — Tom Riello @ 4:25 pm

    In this episode, Tom Riello interviews Tim Troutman on his recent article “Holy Orders and the Sacrificial Priesthood.” Who are the rightful shepherds of Christ’s flock?  Is Holy Orders truly a sacrament?  These and other questions are addressed in this episode.

     

    Download the mp3 by right clicking here.

    April 27, 2010

    Episode 12 – Jeremy Tate’s Conversion

    Filed under: Podcast — Tom Riello @ 7:00 am

    In this podcast episode, Tom Riello interviews Called to Communion regular, Jeremy Tate, on his recent conversion to the Catholic Church.  Jeremy is currently finishing his degree at Reformed Theological Seminary.

     

    Download the mp3 by right clicking here

    March 27, 2010

    Episode 11 – The Canon Question

    Filed under: Podcast — Tags: , , , — Tom Brown @ 12:59 am

    Tom Riello interviews Tom Brown on his recent article on the issue of the canon of scripture.   How do we know which books belong in the Bible?  Who has the authority to answer such a question?  These issues are addressed in this podcast episode.

     

    Download the MP3 here.

    February 21, 2010

    Episode 10 – Our One Year Anniversary

    Filed under: Podcast — Tags: , — Tom Riello @ 10:06 pm

    In this episode, Tom Riello and Tim Troutman reflect on the past liturgical year at Called to Communion.  Topics covered include where CTC has been, where we are now, and where we are headed.

     

    Download the mp3 by right clicking here.

    October 26, 2009

    Episode 9 – On the New Anglican Ordinariates

    Filed under: Podcast — Tags: , , , — Taylor Marshall @ 8:41 am

    Tim Troutman interviews Taylor Marshall, former Episcopal priest, and Andrew Preslar, formerly studying for Anglican orders, on the subject of the new Anglican Ordinariates and what that means for Christianity and ecumenism.

     

    Download the mp3 here.

    September 29, 2009

    Episode 8 – Hermeneutics and the Authority of Scripture

    Filed under: Podcast — Tags: , , — Matt Yonke @ 6:00 am

    Tim Troutman interviews Matt Yonke on his recent lead article entitled “Hermeneutics and the Authority of Scripture.”  The audio is a bit choppy around the four minute mark but that clears up pretty soon.

     

    To download the mp3, right click here.

    August 20, 2009

    Episode 7 – A Dialogue on Conversion

    Filed under: Podcast — Tags: , , — Tim A. Troutman @ 12:41 am

    Tom Riello and Tim Troutman, former PCA members, talk about their respective conversions in this episode.  This is simply a recording of an unscripted conversation with no set topic except, generally speaking, their conversion experiences.   The topics discussed include the canon, Church authority, and the papacy.

     

    To download the mp3, right-click here.

    July 29, 2009

    Episode 6 – Ecclesial Deism

    Filed under: Podcast — Tags: — Tom Riello @ 7:27 pm

    Tom Riello interviews Bryan Cross on the topic of his recent article on Ecclesial Deism.   Also in this episode, Bryan briefly discusses the visiblility of the Church and the necessity of the Petrine ministry.

     

    To download the mp3, right-click here.

    June 27, 2009

    Episode 5 – John Kincaid’s Conversion

    Filed under: Podcast — Tags: , , , — Tom Riello @ 9:57 am

    Tom Riello interviews CTC’s newest member, John Kincaid, on his conversion to the Catholic Church. John Kincaid is a doctoral candidate at Ave Maria University. This is more than a typical conversion story and a bit longer than our previous podcasts but well worth the listen. John shares some insightful theology and gives us a glimpse into why this former Calvinist decided to enter into full communion with the Catholic Church.  

    To download the mp3, right click here.

    For older posts, visit the archives.

From the Blog

I Believe in the Rapture-and it Happens Very Often

Becoming Reformed after a six year sojourn in the evangelical world of Calvary Chapel, I was pleased to give up speculations about the end of the world via the notion of an imminent Rapture. There was a lack of historical support for thinking this way, and there was also a pleasing emphasis on Scripture as opposed to the newspaper. But ...

J.R.R. Tolkien’s Sacramental World, Part Three: Language

This is the third in a three part series. Part One may be read here. (( The first part deals with Memory. Part Two, which considers Matter, is still in the works.  I am sticking to the order of conception, not the order of posting, in numbering this series. )) In this post, I want to make a few remarks ...

Bank Accounts and Justification

Recently a friend reminded me of a common Protestant analogy regarding salvation and merit. The analogy is that sinners have a ‘bank account’ wherewith to ‘pay’ for their eternal salvation. The problem is that man cannot possibly have enough in this account to pay the ‘amount due.’ Faith in Christ is equivalent to having a blank check ...


Podcast

Episode 14 – A Presuppositional Apologist Becomes Catholic

Tom Riello interviews Marc Ayers on the topic of his conversion to the Catholic Church. Marc was a 'disciple' ...


Featured Articles

The Church Fathers on Baptismal Regeneration
featuredimage
According to PCA pastor Wes White, the doctrine of baptismal regeneration is "impossible in the Reformed system." (( See here and here and here. )) By noting this, he intends to show that we should reject the doctrine of baptismal regeneration. But if the evidence for the truth of the doctrine of baptismal regeneration is stronger than the evidence for the truth of the "Reformed system," then the incompatibility of the doctrine of baptismal regeneration and the Reformed system serves as evidence against the Reformed system. Here I present both Patristic and Scriptural evidence for the truth of the doctrine of baptismal regeneration.
How John Calvin Made me a Catholic
featuredimage
This is a guest post by Dr. David Anders. David and his wife completed their undergraduate degrees at Wheaton College in 1992. He subsequently earned an M.A. from Trinity Evangelical Divinity School in 1995, and a Ph.D. from the University of Iowa in 2002, in Reformation history and historical theology.  He was received into the Catholic Church in 2003. He will be on EWTN Live on June 23rd, 7:00 pm Central (8 EST), and may be discussing some of the material from this article.

Christian Unity in the News



The Pope, Montasticism and the Orthodox
Speaking to the Italian magazine 30 Giorni (30 Days), Dominican Fr. Charles Morerod said that Pope Benedict's way of carrying out his ministry leads to his being liked by the Orthodox Church. It is a question of his being similar in nature to the Orthodox bishops, he observed.

15 Anglican Bishops: Some of us Will Unite With Rome

Canadian Anglicans Vote to Unite With Rome

Vatican Prefect Encourages Unity for the Church in China

Patriarch Kirill agrees with Pope on many issues

70 Anglican Clerics Meet With Catholic Bishop